Thailand runs R290 safety test for AC units

The Thailand Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Action (RAC NAMA) has conducted Thailand’s first live safety testing of R290 (propane) for AC units. The results, which support the safety of the flammable refrigerant, have been submitted to the Thai government to assist in its review of the country’s building code, says the organisation.…

The Thailand Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Action (RAC NAMA) has conducted Thailand’s first live safety testing of R290 (propane) for AC units.

The results, which support the safety of the flammable refrigerant, have been submitted to the Thai government to assist in its review of the country’s building code, says the organisation.

The RAC NAMA Project supports Thailand in overcoming hurdles in its move towards increasing the share of natural refrigerant used in the refrigeration and air-conditioning (RAC) technologies.

In particular, the Project helps to ensure the safe application of R290 in AC and refrigeration – giving advice on policies and standards, and training service technicians on the R290-based technology.

Despite having no ozone depleting potential and very low global warming potential, the refrigerant’s high flammability raised operational safety concerns following AC-related fatalities and injuries in the country, which led to tighter controls.

The Safety Demonstration with Source of Ignition and Leak Simulation Test (SOILST) proved that application of R290 is safe if applicable safety standards (for ACs: IEC 60335-2-40) are met, and if installation and servicing are conducted by trained technicians.

“The results of the safety test are useful for Thai producers because they now know what they need to focus on during the design and production of the R290 units,” says Sorntouch Khumdumrongkiat, test supervisor and professor of refrigeration and air conditioning engineering technology at the College of Industrial Technology, King Mongkut’s University of Technology North Bangkok.

“For the consumers, the test should ease their concerns over safety because it proved that there is an absolutely low flammability risk as long as the products conform to the standards.”

Leak simulation tests with different stakeholder groups – testing laboratory, AC and refrigeration producers, and policymakers – were conducted to provide realistic leak scenarios. It determined the range of leak mass flow concentration from R290 units that could be used without any significant fire hazard.

“Most new household and commercial refrigerators nowadays use R600a, which is also a propane just like R290. Even though R290 has higher flammability and the charge size for ACs is higher than refrigerators, it is still safe for application. The crucial part is during the design and production stage, because that is when we try to reduce the risks to an absolute minimal so that the chance of ignition is nearly zero,” says Professor Sorntouch.

“We should also not forget about the technicians who play an important role in installing and maintaining the units. With R290 ACs, there are new parts and processes, so the technicians need to be trained on the new knowledge, techniques and safety protocols. With all this, consumers do not need to worry at all.”

The RAC NAMA is a project commissioned in 2016 by the German Federal Ministry of the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety (BMU) and United Kingdom’s Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS).


Comments

  1. Mathew S. Molk

    Why has R290 not caught on in the US.?

    I am actually an Industrial Electrical/Millwright contractor and am a degreed engineer but I work with all the other trades on a regular basis. Sorry to tell you the REFRIGERATION guys (not the regular HVAC or Tin Knockers) are the most arrogant, pedantic and totally sophomoric bunch of clowns that it has been my misfortune to have run into on any jobsite. in the 50 plus years I have been in the trades. 10% actual knowledge of their trade and 90% covering their actual ignorance and lack of logic. If they didn’t think of it or never saw it before there is no way they can accept ANYTHING. Total jerks all the way (especially when it comes to anything electrical where they are complete morons.)

    ,,,, Here is the simple FACT you will never get across to the mental midgets….. R290 in say a heat pump is actually way less dangerous then a propane furnace or using a propane gas stove. -Anybody old enough to remember the “mustard gas” refrigerators? The ammonia evaporate refrigerator could be deadly. How ’bout Methyl Formate? (That could actually detonate but you wouldn’t care because it would kill you before it reached the explosive limits) Let’s not even talk about a 1-1/4″ gas line running into a restaurant kitchen where they have quick disconnects so they can move and clean under the french fry machines. (In years gone by we did quite a few commercial build outs) The risk imposed by R290 simply doesn’t exist.

    The only explanation I have for the resistance to R290 and 600 is maybe these nimrods get a kickback from Dupont. Then propane is REALLY cheep and there is no patent to worry about and 30% mark up on refrigerant that costs 50 bucks a pound is a lot more the a 30% upcharge on something that goes for 50 CENTS a pound. – The refer guys my not be too good at innovation but they sure know how to turn excess profits.

    Now no question I am not a refrigeration engineer but I do get very deep into life safety, so can R290 catch fire or even in a very, very extreme case explode,,,sure,,,but not anywhere near the loss of life rate caused by natural gas,,,,or the king ‘um all, yall. My bag, Electricity. The risk of using R290 doesn’t even exit compared to say,,, lightning let alone all the other things that can go wrong in a building. (And BTW did you know the propane molecule is too big to fit through a leak that will drain an automotive system in less then a day)

    The Refer people will never understand this but there is a thing called “RISK to GAIN” and R290 is WAY up there on the gain side and way down on the risk end.. We should be using nothing else in automotive, and residential applications. – With the sock puppet in the White House jacking up the price of everything we need all the help we can get. R290.

    R290 Works better, requires less maintenance and costs less and the EPA requires no license to purchase it. And the refer guys hate that.

Leave a Reply to Mathew S. Molk Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *